Reviews

Significant works reviewed by Engelsberg Ideas writers.

Zadie Smith in Barcelona. Credit: NurPhoto SRL
Review

Zadie Smith and the perils of broad-mindedness

Criticism of Zadie Smith raises questions about whether the humanist tradition that shaped 20th-century Anglo-American letters still holds sway today.

Tomiwa Owolade December 23, 2025
Cecil Beaton's portrait of Albert Camus.
Review

Camus’ life without illusion

Albert Camus’ notebooks show a mind that faced the world squarely, appreciating its strangeness and beauty even in the absence of overarching purpose or ideology.

William Fear December 22, 2025
Video “258 Fake” by Ai Weiwei at Andalusian Contemporary Art Center. Credit: Seville2K
Review

The West’s complacency over censorship

Ai Weiwei’s critique of China’s control of thought, speech and action has expanded to include western forms of government. Censorship exists everywhere, he argues, but in democraci..

Bryan Appleyard December 19, 2025
Augustine of Hippo (354-430).
Review

Augustine’s African roots

A new biography of Saint Augustine returns this towering figure of western philosophy to his North African origins, revealing the provincial schisms that shaped his thought.

Daniel Skeffington December 18, 2025
Still from Meeting with Pol Pot.
Review

Facing Pol Pot

The story of three western visitors to Pol Pot’s Cambodia reveals how hard it is to report what one sees rather than what one wants to believe.

Michael Shorris December 12, 2025
A still from The Choral.
Review

Classical music across the classes

The Choral shows how music-making can bind together a community, forging connections between people of different backgrounds, occupations and generations.

Alexandra Wilson December 2, 2025
Hans Holbein the Younger's portrait of Anne of Cleves.
Review

Holbein, master of images

A versatile painter of preternatural talent, Holbein rode his luck to create the most potent images of the reign of Henry VIII.

Michael Prodger December 1, 2025
An aerial photo of Edinburgh taken by Alfred Buckham in 1920.
Review

When the photograph took flight

Alfred Buckham combined audacious aerial photography with groundbreaking techniques to make magnificent art.

Malcolm Forbes November 28, 2025
Jean-Léon Gérôme's The Death of Caesar.
Review

Violence according to Machiavelli

Invoking Machiavelli to legitimise bloodletting in democracies leads nowhere good.

David Wootton November 27, 2025

Download The Engelsberg
Ideas app

The world in your pocket. The app brings together – in one place – our essays, reviews, notebooks, and podcasts.

Download here